
We all know how symmetry reinforces formality in a room, and how, if you want to shake things up, the first thing you'd do is to break up "pairs"--candlesticks, lamps, art, tables, etc. In theory, I know this. In real life, I'm blind. I gravitate to pairs and mirror-images. Some people may refer to this malady as The Matchy-Matchy Disease, Pair-itis, or Noah's Ark Syndrome.
While I would love to blame my decorating fetish on my birthdate--I'm a Libra, the sign of the scales--I cannot. I have an inborn need to pair everything, and I mean EVERYTHING. I can't remember where I read this, but this syndrome, when taken to an extreme (as in my case) can make a room feel static and predictable. For the most part, it's a subliminal thing. (That's one reason I loved yesterday's inspiration photos--the exquisite, asymmetrical accessories helped reinforce informality.)
For fun, let's count the paired objects in my hearth room:
1. Urns on the mantle
2. bird figurines on the mantle
3. Figural lamps
4. scrolly lamps
5. 2 painted chairs
6. 2 upholstered chairs
7. I know there's a 7th
So, with ants in my pants, I rushed around and broke up pairs.
I removed one lamp, switched around the painted chairs, and took down the terra cotta urns. After shopping my house, I couldn't find anything that looked right on the mantle (oh, those flat-screen TVs!!!). Then I realized that I'd really liked the urns on the mantle (although I'd like to find old books for "platforms"), and I'd just have to live with some degree of this syndrome.
But there's another problem--the Mirror Image. When I look at the overall symmetry and balance of this room, the left side is visually heavier than the right. The draperies, covering all those windows, accentuate the imbalance. One solution would be to add drapery panels to the door, however we use that door, and besides, drapery panels (I don't sew!) would mess with my budget, and I'd never get around to other rooms.
But!! A screen or a live plant might work. I called the greenhouse, and they have a beautiful 9' ficus. They are holding it for me. :-) Tra-la-la. I think a tree will actually be better than draperies, because it will add softness--and also, this room really needs something organic. If I can keep it alive, it will be a much better bargain. (Note to self: talk to Tootsie about Ficus benjaminas!)
A Few Other Things:
Just as an experiment, I moved the fireplace screen (a housewarming present from my mother) into the library, but I may move it back. I have a plain iron screen somewhere in the garage. And I want to compare them.
Also, I'm moving the sofa table and replacing it with an old, oval burled table--it used to be in the tv room & is now in my granddaughter's room.

It's deeper than the current table, so I will have to push the sofa forward a bit.
I moved one of the lamps into the kitchen for now. It was painful to break up this pair, but at least they aren't terribly far away--they can blow kisses.
Oh Gollum -
ReplyDeleteI loved this tour of your gorgeous kitchen/hearth room combination. What a lovely home you have, I can't wait to see how it all comes together with the ficus and the table. (etc)
I like the changes. I'd keep the fireplace screen in the library. Strangely enough, my eye goes more to the t.v. when the screen is there.
ReplyDeleteI don't care what you do to your house.....matchy, matchy or not it always looks BEAUTIFUL!!!
ReplyDeleteI love it when you let loose and write and write and write. And I'm a huge fan of the ficus SO, go for it.
ReplyDeleteGollum, I must suffer from that Noah's Ark Syndrome, Pairitis!, coz I loved everything you did but felt decidedly un-easy when you moved one of the painted chairs and one of the lamps and god forbid you separate Helena and Hunk in the dining room!. The Fiscus Benjaminus will look perfect, I love that you have a "three piece suite". I am off on my hols now and hubby is about to pull the plug, ciao for now, Kathy.
ReplyDeleteI love to change things, it makes the room always look fresh. To leave it the same way for long periods of time would drive me nuts. Scoripo...Kathy
ReplyDeleteNoah, a good name for the mule. ;-)
ReplyDeleteGM Gollum... Well after reading this I did a look about my LR and low and behold I don't have no matchy, matchy at all!!! Of course being a collector of antiques its hard to find lamps, chairs,tables,stain glasses windows etc. anything in 2 to match...
ReplyDeleteI love your beautiful home..no matter what you do it will always be beautiful.. Now which Yorkie with his nose up in the air is the one on your side bar?? I si remember this Kitchen from RMS and the Rooster you have above your stove that looks like wood that your son got you!!! great blog today..give those yorkies some lovin from me!!! hugs and smiles OH and if anyone can tell you about the Ficus it would be Toots, she out camping this week and I know she doing a number on the trees haha!!
Good Morning Gollum,
ReplyDeleteWow girl, I think you have to slow down a bit, you've got my head spinning. LOL.... Did you get the other room, projects finished yet? It's the middle of Summer, what are you going to do for Fall? Spring and Fall cleaning time are when I feel that urge.
I'm afraid I've been accused of being 'MATCHY, MATCHY' too, for one of my RMS post showing our master bedroom. I never did get around to re-posting when I changed for the seasons. I'm afraid I liked your room as it was. I think I have developed some kind of 'control issue' as I've gotten older and maybe that's why I like the idea of things matching.
As it's been pointed out by others, your rooms have to feel right to YOU, so re-arrange them so that they make YOU feel good. You know in the end we'll love what you do. Can't wait to see the end results.
Thanks for sharing......
'D'
P.S. I haven't had good results with a Ficus,I've tried several times and all my leaves kept falling off, and I'd follow all the instructions I received from the garden center. :( Good luck with yours.
Good morning, Gollum. I think however you arrange your furniture and accessories in your house, it will still look beautiful. I like both arrangements. I do that a lot at home too. I switch things around for a while and then back to where it was again and then switch again. It's a cycle.
ReplyDeleteOoh girl, don't smack me, but I liked it better all matchy matchy!!!!!!!!!!!! LOL
ReplyDeleteJustine :o )
Hi Gollum,
ReplyDeleteI have the same syndrome. I loved your first picture of your hearth room (always have!) and didn't notice so much of the symmetry until you started pointing it all out 1,2, 3...because it was so gorgeous. Symmetry just makes me feel comfortable. But, sometimes change is a good thing and moving stuff around makes it feel new and more interesting. I've always loved your gorgeous home, you have a phenomenal talent...follow your heart (besides you can always put it all back, haha!).
Desiree
Good Morning Gollum:
ReplyDeleteFirst...thankyou for visiting my blog. And Crumpet says "hey" right back at Mister & co.
Next...after snooping through your home I've come to a conclusion. If you piled everything you own in the center of the room...it would STILL BE GORGEOUS!! So many beautiful things in a beautiful setting. OH MY! Your home is one of those places I could move into and not change a single thing...and I can't say that very often. Not just because you have gorgeous things...but because you put them together in a way that isn't stuffy or standoffish. Your home says "welcome, kick off your shoes and stay awhile". Quite an amazing accomplishment...but then we're not surprised coming from you. Thanks for letting us peek in your home...we've been waiting a looooong time.
***Gosh, I just LOVE waking up n' coming here, cuppa in hand, ready to "visit" before really starting the day ~ kinda like ladies did "in the old days", only THIS is "virtual", of course! (Funny, the warmth n' friendship still seems to BE there, tho!). You have some of T-H-E most beautiful n interesting pieces, GG, & that burled wood table is no exception ~~~ SOOO charming! Your keen eye allows you to "play" w/ arranging n' re-arranging (& isn't that always such a "fun" part of it all?!), & you inevitably end up w/ a truly special, and enchanting, "y-o-u" space!!! Ohhhh, and the glimpse of your pool from behind the flowers???~~~~ SOOOO INVITING!!! Such fun to see n' learn something new everyday! Merci!!! Love, Linda
ReplyDelete***BTW, I keep meaning to compliment/thank you for the PERFECT l-e-n-g-t-h of "GOLLUM'S COLUMNS"! I could read 100 of them a day, but the length of EACH, INDIVIDUAL writing is perfection... it lets one finish up with "one thought", instead of going in 100 different directions! (Hope you get my drift here!)~~~ XO
ReplyDeleteI am drawn to the Noahs Ark look, myself, I guess it gives me a sense of security..... (one is a lonely number)!!! LOL
ReplyDeleteHowever, change is good and like you said, makes things "fresher".
P.S.
(I think the little ones are miffed that they didn't get to be in any of the pictures this time) :0)
(santamaker)
Gollum, here's a bold move for ya....have you thought of painting the dome ceiling of your hearth room a "terracotta" color? Just looking at your photos and thought that it would be a "WOW"!
ReplyDeleteGollum-I love watching you work through design 'dilemmas'...I'm always fighting pairitis and thought that I was alone! After working on my living room for two years, I've pretty much conquered the pair problem, but I'm still far from finished because the room is suffering from too much of a good thing. My husband and I have finally admitted that we should have resisted buying a floral sofa to match a floral chair even though we loved the fabric! Too matchy, matchy and too difficult to accessorize! What were we thinking??? I'm actually looking at SLIPCOVERS for a brand new sofa, and I've been trying to talk my sweetie into a tree for a blah corner. He objects to the tree because our cat will probably nibble it to a premature death!!! At least he's willing to try a slipcover. Can't wait to see your tree in place. Nancy
ReplyDeleteI think many of us are guilty of the 'paired syndrome' particularly if we strive for 'balance'. Maybe to some its considered a decorating sin, but it's not such a bad character flaw is it? :) :)
ReplyDeletePhotos can be deceiving, but I feel with the removal of the f/p screen you MAY have created an anchoring 'black' void when paired with the 'black' T.V. (Just a thought and okay I admit I am partial to the beautiful screen.)
I absolutely love your gorgeous home and I'm sure the addition of the Fiscus will just be perrrrrrrfect.
HAVE A BEAUTIFUL DAY GOLLUM!
POOR GOLLUM.I MUST HAVE YOUR DISEASE,BECAUSE I LIKED YOUR ROOM FAR MORE BEFORE YOU MOVED EVERYTHING.TO ME,NOW,IT DOESN'T LOOK RIGHT!!!!!!!!PLEASE FOR YOUR SAKE AND MINE,PUT IT ALL BACK.HAHA.....ANN
ReplyDeleteI like the one chair by the fireplace now better. I think I actually liked the other chair and table where you had it behind (or in this pic in front) of the sofa better.
ReplyDeleteYou have a beautiful home.
Oh and where'd the grey doggie go?
ReplyDeleteNancy Jane, I have to admit that I love florals, and I love matching upholstery. If you are reading this, I have a question or 2--did your sofa/chair come with pillows and if so, did you try something different here and there? And did you try a throw?
ReplyDeleteI am agreeing with you guys about the BEFORE being better. lol Plus, we need lamps for reading more than we need asymmetry.
ReplyDeleteThe Yorkie with his nose in the air is Mister. :-)
Becky, the big greyhound is on the floor beside the right chair.
Justine, the other day you asked if I made the pillows in the breakfast room--no!!!! lol I was a home ec major in high school and made a zipperless, drawstring skirt for my senior project. (But I did learn to make great mashed potatoes.)
I'm off to get the ficus. Thank you all for your wonderful comments. I feel happy and lucky to be a part of this great design community. It really does take a village!
Don't a just love playing with the placement of things?! I do, I move things around all the time...then I sit and look at it from evey angle of the room to see if it feels right, if it does it stays...for a little while anyway! lol. Beautiful!
ReplyDeleteHi Gollum :)
ReplyDeleteI like it both ways!
Have you ever thought of putting an empty frame around the flat screen? I thought of doing it myself, but cannot for the life of me find a frame big enough and Rich hasn't had time to build me one.
By the way, make sure the ficus isn't by an air vent. They don't like it. Plus, once you put it there and it's happy, do not for any reason ever move it. They don't like that either. They're kind of a pissy plant LOL
Hugs,
rue (the scorpio)
We have you to thank for bringing this villiage together.
ReplyDeletegollum, I think I like the symmetry better, maybe not everything but most things. It almost looked like it needed to be straightened, I guess I have Noah's Ark syndrom, too. But you do have the most gorgeous things. Connie
ReplyDelete***Just writing a TU note (yes, I W-R-I-T-E them!) and "bing"! ~~~ The light on my head went on~~~ ah ha!!! "STONEHENGE"!!! Yes, THAT's what I was thinking of earlier, re the peek at your pool thru the flowers, GG!!! FASCINATING PLACE!!! IN fact, LOTS of your surroundings remind me of it!!! How UTTERLY FABULOUS, you LUCKY gal!!! All that STONE... sooo yummy!!!~~~ BTW, saw RUE'S note, above, re framing a TV. I designed one for a guest room where their TV HAD to go on what I call an "entrance wall"...our carpenter made it and wow! ~ looks fab & everyone (including DH) likes it! He WAS going to make them for all the other TVs, but he had to move to Oregon for a fab job offer ~ oh poop! I A-M happy for him, REALLY! BUUUT, to be TOTALLY honest, I AM just "sad" for ME! "Boo hoo"! (Told my DH I needed my HANDYMAN as much as my HUSBAND!!! Thank heavens he laughed!!!)~~~ Smiles!
ReplyDelete***Interesting to see an astrological sign here n' there... "vedddddy interesting", girlfriends! (And boyfriends, too!)...Now where's the book I had on that?????? (If I HAD those bookshelves I want, I'd KNOW where it is! Argh!)~~~ Love, Linda ("Cancer")
ReplyDeleteAfternoon, Gollum! Well, if you'll let me come over, I'll shop in your house for the rest of the day! Gollum, you have just beautiful things and with your decorating sense, everything you do is amazing! I like your hearth room the way you mixed it up. Now sit down with a cuppa tea and relax!
ReplyDeleteBe a sweetie,
Shelia ;)
G, you can do no wrong. I would love to play with your rooms! I like it both ways. I was so surprized to learn that you are a libra, as I do not usually like libras...lol all the people in my life that cause my head to hurt are libras lol I guess I am going to have to look for a new reason for that, because I sure DO like you! vickydarnell
ReplyDeleteWent back for take 2, and I do like it better not so matched. Just adding my 2 cents worth! vicky
ReplyDeleteBoth ways look good to me.What is your belief on three's? When I buy I tend to do the three thing.
ReplyDeleteI like matchy matchy. I think it flows better. And you have such beautiful things. display away in pairs. love J
ReplyDeleteok, here's the deal. I thought I wasn't a matchy matchy person, but I do gravitate toward symmetry. In my humble opinion, they are 2 different things, and I don't think you are "matchy-matchy" at all. I think that means that all of your fabrics, etc. match one another. I LOVE symmetry, although that is probably not apparent to most who view my home. I probably don't have many pairs in my home, because I, like Gloria, only buy antiques or bargains (you don't find 2 chairs that match ea. other if you're bargain-hunting!). But, I do love to pair things that are similar in size and shape. It is SO much fun to watch you making your decisions about arrangements. I guess we all do it in similar fashion, but you sound SO much like me. I have those "moving men" I put under furniture, and move things around constantly. My husband of 40 yrs has become so accustomed to it, he sometimes doesn't notice for months! Laurie
ReplyDeleteWell, we have the ficus (the poor thing was windwhipped on the drive home, and it has fallen over twice). I hope I can get it repotted in time for a photo. :-)
ReplyDeleteDishDiva, I do like triplets and placing things in 3s (or 5's or 7's). When it comes to tablescapes and vignettes, though, I consider the 3-5-7-9 "rule" on an individual basis.
Laurie, I think a room is much, much more interesting when items are similar but not identical, as you mentioned. It takes so much longer to find them, but it's worth it.
Hi there Gollum, Being a "balanced gal" myself (as one RMSer pointed out) I, of course, like the room the way you had it before you you broke things up but that is only because my brain thrives on balance and symmetry. Enjoying your blog and even more so now that I know who you are! Cheers! :) Rachel (mackenziesmom01)
ReplyDeleteGollum,
ReplyDeleteI definitely love the lamp on your kitchen counter, and the burled table and chairs. I like things to match but not necessarily matchy-matchy. Although, I am somewhat guilty of that myself. I'm not fond of symmetry. But I do like to look for balance and weight in the room. You are right it's those darn big black TV's. Candace Olson had a great idea on an episode where she had the TV framed and a painting automatically closed over the screen when not in use. It was way cool! ~ Robyn
Good evening Gollum's girls and guys! I have a question Gollum... did you move it all back yet? Just wondering. I'm not a matchy, matchy kind of person but after touring my home, I find that there are more "pairs" of things than I would have imagined! I'm a firm believer in balance but not necessarily symmetry. I love any plant in a room as long as it isn't plastic so I can't wait to see the post of the ficus. But, listen to Rue! They are sensitive little suckers! Gollum, when I get one of these wild hairs to move everything in the world around, my home looks like a tornado went through it. It definitely puts a smile on my face when it all comes together with a new look though. I love change.... Can't wait for the next installment Gollum! Carol (Cancer)...survivor
ReplyDeleteHi Gollum - On my sofa I have 2 striped pillows that are okay color wise, but I think too flat and too large. I tried a throw, but it was an off color. Glad you revived these ideas because I'm not big on slipcovers. As soon as I can break free from the gardens, I need an accessory trip! If that doesn't work, I'll need an upholsterer! N. (Hope the Ficus has recovered from the move!)
ReplyDeleteHi Gollum! I just found your blog a couple of weeks ago. I kept hearing about it on RMS. By the way,I love your spaces;) I'm a Libra too and think I have a little Noah's ark syndrome. I went through my house and found several pairs of things. I feel the need for balance! Anyways- I love whatever you do. It will turn out perfect balanced or not!! Kristen
ReplyDeleteI am proud to be Matchy Matchy!!Lol!! I can't help it! Like you gollum I LOVE pairs of things! I also am more comfortable with formality (antique nutso here *winks*) Which I think pairs of things lend themselves to. So I vote for the matchy matchy!! Oh and I wish you the best with your ficus. I can't for the life of me keep em alive.....but that's pretty much true of plants in general. What a gorgeous home you have! Vanna
ReplyDeleteGollum, I love matchy matchy! I am so afraid of anything else. (smile) I am always afraid of making a mistake! Matchy Matchy is safe. (smile)
ReplyDeleteYour LR is stunning!
Donna
To me, matchy-matchy is when your rooms look like furniture manufacturer's ads. Or Decorating Den. Or Waverly. Your home is no where NEAR matchy-matchy!
ReplyDelete***As my dear friend, CAROL (AKA "Duchess") said, I too think it should all just be "balanced out" ~~~ you know, a pair here, a single there ~~~ what PLEASES AESTHETICALLY and/or just "makes ya happy"!!! And personally, I can't "HELP" it, but if it LOOKS like a plant/ tree/ flower, then it SHOULD be...real! If it can't be, for a variety of reasons we all know about, then an alternative CAN be found, IMHO...Hugs, Linda
ReplyDeleteI love love love your room, GORGEOUS!
ReplyDeleteI also tend to lean in the direction of attempting some kind of overall balance, at least when it comes to the visual "pull" and "weight" of a room. So no completely empty spaces/walls for me....BUT - having said that, and this is just my "2 cents"....there is a difference between "matchy-matchy" and balanced (sometimes these are achieved together, but not always) and you don't need what's on one side to match completely with the other in order to strike and overall visual balance.
For example, on one side of my TV armoire, there is a chandelier dangling over a fairly sizeable statue, and on the other side, just a simple wall sconce with shells and a photo (of course there is also a hallway on the right side, which visually adds alittle something). Somehow, even though the vignette on the left does look "heavier" and offers more to look at, therefore demanding more attention, or "pull", there is a harmonious, albeit whimsical balance achieved between the two sides. And nothing else in this space, besides two hand-forged wrought iron scones on another wall in this room, is matchy-matchy.
I'd love to post up a pic so you could see whatI'm talking about but darn it all, I can't figure out how to do that! I am taking baby steps with this blogging thing, LOL!
I want those clouds on my MBR ceiling! They are GORGEOUS!
ReplyDeleteDid you do that yourself? I've seen a cloud painting kit in the hardware store.....please share....
hi!!! i AM SO HAPPY TO BE ABLE TO LEAVE A COMMENT. i HAVE TO THANK lINDA ("mOM") FOR HELPING ME!!!! Anyway, I, too, have the matchy disease, when I do post you will see that I am pretty symetrical with things....but it pleases my EYE and that is what I go for. Your home is just gorgeous so do JUST what pleases you!!!! Oh! I will be back again...and again...finally am able to do this BLOG thing!!! Pinky aka szpinky from RMS.
ReplyDeleteI am guilty of matchy matchy disease! It is really hard to do the things it takes to change it. I am also a very sentimental fool....
ReplyDelete